Quicken vs Mint: A Comprehensive Comparison of Essential Financial Tools (2024)

If you are a former Mint user, you are well aware that as of March 23, 2024 Mint has shut down and been "reimagined as part of Intuit Credit Karma". If you miss the features offered by Mint and are looking for a viable alternative, you came to the right place.

In this article I will be looking at Quicken vs Mint side-by-side. I’ll be taking a close look at the features and pricing of both platforms so you can determine if Quicken is a viable replacement to Mint. Read on for the benefits and drawbacks of one of the most popular, longest running personal finance platforms available.

If you decide Quicken is the replacement you have been searching for, Click Here to save up to 40% on your subscription cost.

Quicken: A Bit of History

Personally, before diving into any software, I appreciate knowing its roots. Quicken, a well-established name in personal finance management, first graced the world of technology back in 1983, designed initially for MS-DOS and Apple II systems.

Today, it stands as a venerable figure in the finance software realm, boasting a robust 40-year legacy that resonates with many users, especially beginners who favor its straightforward interface.

Over the decades, Quicken has evolved significantly, transitioning from a basic desktop application to a versatile suite that includes tailored solutions for various platforms like Windows and Mac, along with mobile apps for iPhone, iPad, and Android devices.

It offers a range of products to meet varied personal and business finance needs, from Quicken Home & Business to Simplifi by Quicken, ensuring it remains relevant to meet the diverse needs of modern users.

Now that you know a little bit about Quicken’s history, I will compare the main features of the two platforms, so you can decide if Quicken is the best Mint alternative for you.

Quicken vs Mint: Budgeting

In comparing Quicken vs Mint for budgeting, both apps excel with strong features for managing personal finances effectively. Mint, was known for its free, user-friendly interface, allows detailed tracking of expenses and categorization. It excels in simplicity and visual appeal, making it ideal for casual budgeting.

Quicken, while requiring a subscription, offers more advanced budgeting tools. It provides budget forecasts based on expected income and upcoming bills, helping users predict future balances. Additionally, Quicken's annual view feature gives a comprehensive overview of yearly financial activities, aiding in long-term financial planning.

For those who need in-depth financial management, Quicken's enhanced features make it the better choice for detailed budget planning and monitoring.

Quicken vs Mint: Investment Tracking Features

When evaluating investment tracking features between Quicken and Mint, I've found that Quicken typically offers a more detailed suite of tools, particularly beneficial for those heavily invested in managing their financial portfolios.

Quicken’s capabilities are highlighted in their Premier and Home & Business plans, where you can actively monitor investment fees, assess true market returns, and manage investment accounts with precision.

With Quicken, users can:

  • View comprehensive investment fees and returns.
  • Set up detailed stock watchlists to keep an eye on potential market movements.
  • Observe actual and target portfolio allocations.
  • Utilize tools like Morningstar’s X-Ray to deeply evaluate investment strategies.
  • Generate IRR and ROI reports, which are crucial for assessing the effectiveness of investments.
  • Compare portfolio performance directly against market benchmarks.
  • Plan for taxes with data on realized and unrealized gains.
  • Explore “what if” scenarios to understand potential tax consequences of selling assets.

Mint, in contrast, served more as an aggregator of financial accounts. It didn’t offer the granularity of Quicken but is efficient for a broad overview of your financial situation. Mint’s features included:

  • Aggregation of data from various financial institutions, displaying overall performance.
  • Breakdowns of investment allocations and performance, including top and worst performers.
  • Comparisons to major indices like NASDAQ and SPY to gauge overall market standing.
  • A fee analyzer that reviews charges from investment advisors and bank accounts, aiming to eliminate unnecessary expenses and enhance investment returns.

For those deeply engaged in refining their financial life and seeking detailed insights to inform their financial goals, Quicken’s robust tools offer a significant advantage.

Quicken vs Mint: Credit Monitoring Tools Comparison

When it comes to credit monitoring tools, both Quicken and Mint offer useful features that help manage credit scores and credit card accounts, but there are some nuances to consider.

Quicken focuses on comprehensive financial management and includes credit score monitoring as part of its service. Users receive credit scores updated quarterly from Equifax, which are presented as VantageScores rather than FICO scores.

This is a typical approach for many free credit score monitoring services. Quicken helps you understand various factors impacting your score, such as on-time payments, credit usage, and credit inquiries, which is invaluable for maintaining or improving your financial health.

Additionally, Quicken's alerts system is designed to notify users about important financial thresholds and activities, such as:

  • High balances on credit card accounts
  • Budget overages in specific categories
  • Key investment and tax dates
  • Bill reminders

In contrast, Mint, was known more broadly as a personal finance app, providing more frequent credit monitoring updates. Mint offered credit scores from TransUnion and updated whenever new information was reported by creditors.

Mint also educated users on how scores are calculated and ways to improve them. For everyday financial tracking, Mint allowed users to set up customized alerts for:

  • Unusual spending or budget overruns
  • Updates on credit scores and other changes
  • Low balances in any account
  • Drops in available credit
  • Large purchases
  • Bank fees

Quicken vs Mint: My Verdict

As I reflect on the robust capabilities of Quicken compared to the now-retired Mint, it's clear to me that Quicken stands out as a premier personal finance software. With its deep roots in the financial software industry and a continuous evolution over the past four decades, Quicken has proven itself as a dynamic and reliable tool for detailed financial management.

For those who prioritize comprehensive oversight of their financial life, including budgeting features, investment performance, and credit monitoring, Quicken offers unmatched depth. Its ability to track investment accounts with precision and provide insightful analytics through tools like Morningstar's X-Ray positions it as a superior choice for serious investors.

Additionally, the tailored alerts for key financial activities such as high credit card debt, budget thresholds, and investment opportunities make it invaluable for staying on top of your finances.

In essence, if you're seeking a powerful and integrative approach to manage your finances, transitioning to Quicken from Mint can enhance your capability to meet and exceed your financial goals.

Explore Quicken’s diverse features and see how it can transform your approach to personal finance. With plans starting as low as $3.99 there is no reason not to start your journey with Quicken today and take control of your financial future. Remember, using my exclusive link will get you up to 40% off your subscription costs.

Quicken vs Mint: A Comprehensive Comparison of Essential Financial Tools (2024)

FAQs

Quicken vs Mint: A Comprehensive Comparison of Essential Financial Tools? ›

Quicken vs Mint: Budgeting

Is Mint better than Quicken? ›

Quicken has much more functionality and can grow with you over time. It's also better than Mint if you're a small business owner or are managing rental properties. Quicken is also better than Mint for tracking investments and planning your retirement.

Is Mint owned by Quicken? ›

On November 2, 2009, Intuit announced its acquisition of Mint.com was complete. The former CEO of Mint.com, Aaron Patzer, was named vice president and general manager of Intuit's personal finance group, responsible for Mint.com and all Quicken online, desktop, and mobile offerings.

Is Quicken good for home finances? ›

Overall, Quicken is a powerful and robust tool for managing your finances. If you want to understand your money and plan for the future, Quicken might be the right fit for you. With that being said, our verdict is that Quicken is likely to be the best fit only for entrepreneurs, small businesses, and the self-employed.

Does Mint sync with Quicken? ›

Importing Categories: Quicken Simplifi will import your Categories from Mint. After importing your transactions, navigate to your Categories list under Settings. You'll see sections for "Mint Expense" and "Mint Income" where you can edit or move your Categories to ensure everything is properly set up.

Why is Mint shutting down? ›

In less than two weeks, the budgeting app Mint — which once had 3.6 million active users, including me — will shut down forever. According to its parent company, Intuit, Mint wasn't making enough money, so Intuit began the app's closure in January.

Is Mint going away in 2024? ›

Mint will go offline March 23, 2024.

But that's far from the only option. Budgeting apps are a great way to get a grip on your finances.

Why is Intuit closing Mint? ›

But in the years since the purchase, Intuit failed to expand Mint into the success that many saw as possible. Last year, the company said sales from the app weren't material to revenue despite having millions of monthly active users. Intuit officially closed Mint last month.

Why is Mint going away? ›

Mint recently announced: “Reimagining Mint as part of Intuit Credit Karma will expand our capabilities,” which is them trying to put a positive spin on the fact that they're shutting down their budgeting app capabilities—and Mint budgeters won't be able to access their budgeting accounts or continue budgeting starting ...

What is replacing Mint? ›

What is replacing the Mint app? Intuit, the company behind the Mint app, folded Mint users into another one of their products: Credit Karma. Many users decided to adopt new apps, like Empower and Monarch Money, rather than go to Credit Karma.

What are the disadvantages of Quicken? ›

Cost: Quicken can be expensive, especially if you are looking for advanced features such as bill payment and investment tracking. Limited bank integration: We've had difficulties connecting our bank accounts with Quicken, making it challenging to keep track of our spending and reconcile our accounts.

Do people still use Quicken? ›

Since its initial launch 40 years ago, Quicken has remained the #1 best-selling personal finance software on the market with the same mission: to help our customers lead healthy financial lives.

Is Quicken no longer owned by Intuit? ›

Quicken is a personal finance management application originally developed and offered by Intuit, Inc. Intuit sold Quicken to H.I.G. Capital in 2016, and H.I.G.

Is Mint as good as Quicken? ›

Quicken vs Mint: Budgeting

Mint, was known for its free, user-friendly interface, allows detailed tracking of expenses and categorization. It excels in simplicity and visual appeal, making it ideal for casual budgeting. Quicken, while requiring a subscription, offers more advanced budgeting tools.

What is the difference between Mint and Quicken simplifi? ›

Quicken by Simplifi presents a flexible, personalized budgeting approach, adapting to monthly spending habits for a straightforward experience. Mint utilized traditional budgeting tools, requiring more time for setup and maintenance but providing detailed spending limits and custom budget categories.

Is Mint completely free? ›

Does it cost money to use Mint? Mint is free to use and includes many useful features. A premium ad-free app version is available to iOS users for $4.99 monthly. You don't need to spend money to use Mint.

Is Quicken a good Mint alternative? ›

Quicken. Quicken offers two Mint competitors: Classic and Simplifi. Both products charge for their services, ranging from $2 to $9 a month, depending on the tier you choose, while Mint was free.

What are the disadvantages of Intuit Mint? ›

Pros and Cons of Mint
Pros of MintCons of Mint
Ease of useLack of investing features
Free to useIntrusive ads
Financial summaries and alerts via email or text messageProblems with account synchronization
Free credit score courtesy of EquifaxLack of bill pay feature
3 more rows

Is anything better than Mint? ›

Monarch is better than Mint ever was. Mint would consistently have trouble importing data from several of my accounts. Every month or two, I'd need to reconnect my accounts to Mint. Those same accounts stay linked up in Monarch.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ouida Strosin DO

Last Updated:

Views: 5656

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ouida Strosin DO

Birthday: 1995-04-27

Address: Suite 927 930 Kilback Radial, Candidaville, TN 87795

Phone: +8561498978366

Job: Legacy Manufacturing Specialist

Hobby: Singing, Mountain biking, Water sports, Water sports, Taxidermy, Polo, Pet

Introduction: My name is Ouida Strosin DO, I am a precious, combative, spotless, modern, spotless, beautiful, precious person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.